Your dog is killed while chasing a car. When the man knocks on your door to tell you, he has the bloody dog in his arms. He smiles I hit your dog…
Your move, writer.
Start with that smile — it's the hinge the whole piece swings on. Play it as horror and you don't need a monster: a man grinning while holding a dead dog is already wrong enough, and the story can live entirely in the narrator's frozen half-second of deciding whether to scream or invite him in for coffee. Play it as grief instead, and the smile becomes tragic rather than sinister — shock does strange things to faces, and he's been rehearsing an apology the whole walk over that came out sideways. Or go quiet and strange: write it from the dog's point of view in the seconds before impact, so the reader arrives at that doorstep already mourning, and the man's smile becomes almost beside the point. Whichever way you lean, let silence do more work than dialogue in that first exchange.
Comments